Club Penguin Island

From Crappy Games Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Club Penguin Island
Club Penguin Island.jpg
Want to play, Membership
Genre: Massively multiplayer online role-playing game
Platforms: iOS
Release Date: Android, iOS: March 29, 2017
Windows, macOS: November 30, 2017
Delist Date: December 20, 2018
Game Engine: Unity
Developer: Disney Canada Inc.
Publisher: Disney Mobile
Franchise: Club Penguin
Previous Game: Club Penguin

Club Penguin Island was a massively-multiplayer online role-playing game for mobile devices, Microsoft Windows, and Mac OS X. It was the successor of Club Penguin and released worldwide on March 29, 2017. The game's public beta testing period took place in Australia and New Zealand from December 15, 2016, and in Canada from January 13, 2017, to its release date.

On September 27, 2018, an official news post was posted announcing that Club Penguin Island would be closing down by the end of the year. The multiplayer servers closed down on December 20th, 2018. Offline Mode, which would allow players to continue playing the game in a limited form after the closure of the servers, was made available the next day.

Why It Sucked

  1. Microtransactions: The game offered a paid membership subscription, and without one the game becomes boring and dull. Lacking membership makes you unable to buy and share party supplies, collect exclusive items, access unlimited clothing creation, and use gear (with the exception of the Jackhammer but jack hammer is only used in the context of specific missions).
    • The game did offer a free seven-day membership trial but you couldn't start it without entering your credit card details. If you didn't cancel the membership early enough, you would have been automatically charged the membership fee after those seven days.
  2. It cloned many other MMO games, such as Pirate 101 and Monkey Quest (which shut down on September 26, 2014), making it not stand out among these much better titles.
  3. Quests that boil down to collecting a few items and running back to the quest-giver; they were nothing more than fetch quests.
  4. A poorly executed leveling system that had the player unlock things as they level up. It inspired other mediocre games like BlockStarPlanet to do the same thing.
  5. It lacks a lot of features that the original Club Penguin had. Most notably the Puffles, which were one of the biggest things on the original.
  6. The paper-thin plot. While Club Penguin had paper-thin plots, they were passable as the game was not entirely focused on them.
  7. Club Penguin was discontinued in favor of this, and Disney does not want anyone trying to bring back the original experience.
  8. The developers kept releasing useless parties rather than focusing on the features the players wanted, like Puffles.
  9. Most of the soundtrack has been recycled from the original Club Penguin.
  10. Getting banned for either saying harmless words or no apparent reason was easy.
  11. Excessive amounts of glitches.
  12. Terrible amounts of lag that could sometimes crash the game, especially on Android devices.
  13. At launch, the game looked unfinished.

Redeeming Qualities

  1. From an economic standpoint, the game's existence can be justified. Club Penguin was suffering from a low fanbase at the time, Adobe Flash was getting outdated, and it was costing way too much to continue maintenance.
  2. While the multiplayer and online elements are no longer available, Offline Mode allows players to continue playing the game after the servers closed. It also allows players to access the Debug Mode and change the appearance of the island.
  3. Disney attempted to fix the damage caused by the membership by adding more new things to it, like igloos.
  4. The graphics were way better than the original game and the penguin models no longer looked like triangular penguins.
  5. The PC port of the game runs more fluid and stable than the mobile version.
  6. Some songs like Epic Island, The Perfect Day, and Brightest Days are pretty good to listen to.
  7. The voice acting is decent.


The game's announcement, along with the closure of the original Club Penguin on January 30, 2017, had upset many fans of the original.

Club Penguin Island garnered mostly negative user reviews upon its worldwide release, and many players criticized Disney's choice to discontinue the original.





17 months ago
Score 4
Thank god this game burned in the ritual of deslisted games


15 months ago
Score 0
Yeah, finally...


15 months ago
Score 4
Ironically, the word "Toontown" was censored in Club Penguin Island. I guess they don't want people talking about the much better game.


14 months ago
Score 4

"The game did offer a free seven-day membership trial but you couldn't start it without entering your credit card details."

It's not free if you have to pay for it! What the hell, Disney!


14 months ago
Score 0
I’d rather pay for that game than Adobe Flash.


7 months ago
Score 1
Unpopular opinion, but this game was pretty underrated. Yeah sure, it wasn't the original CP in any way, but it was alright.


4 months ago
Score 1
Club Penguin Online is even worse than this game.

XXSeph MySpaceXx

4 months ago
Score 0
oh god, I've heard about how much of a terrible person the creator of CPO was. thank god CPO got shut down


2 months ago
Score 0
At least CP Rewritten is not run by a terrible person. But sadly it may get shut down soon


2 months ago
Score 0
I personally really loved this one. But maybe that’s because I had membership.

You are not allowed to post comments.